TY - JOUR
T1 - Interventions Targeting the Mental Health and Well-being of Care-Experienced Children and Young People: Mixed-Methods Systematic Review with Stakeholder Consultation to Inform Transportability and Adaptability to UK Context
AU - Evans, Rhiannon
AU - MacDonald, Sarah
AU - Trubey, Rob
AU - Melendez-Torres, G J
AU - Robling, Michael
AU - Willis, Simone
AU - Boffey, Maria
AU - Wooders, Charlotte
AU - Vinnicombe, Soo
AU - Noyes, Jane
PY - 2024/12/1
Y1 - 2024/12/1
N2 - Care-experienced children and young people are at increased risk of poor mental health and well-being, and suicide-related outcomes. There is an evidence-base for intervention effectiveness, but this is primarily from the USA. The present systematic review synthesised evidence for international interventions, exploring potential transportability and adaptability to the UK. We constructed an evidence map, and syntheses of intervention effectiveness, process evaluations and economic evaluations. We conducted seven stakeholder consultations with care-experienced young people, carers and professionals, to appraise transportability and adaptability. We identified sixty-four interventions, with 124 associated study reports. Seventy-seven were from the USA. There was limited effectiveness in targeting mental health, although there were promising approaches. Few approaches targeted well-being and suicide. Context factors, identified by the review and confirmed by stakeholders, may inhibit delivery: insufficient resources; time, emotional and cognitive burden; challenging interprofessional relationships; non-responsiveness to young people’s needs; and discounting of carers’ knowledge. Stakeholders recommended peer mentoring by other care-experienced individuals and system-change models that facilitate an attachment and/or trauma-informed ethos. Adaptation of existing approaches may be required to account for the context factors. Further intervention work is needed to target well-being and suicide.
AB - Care-experienced children and young people are at increased risk of poor mental health and well-being, and suicide-related outcomes. There is an evidence-base for intervention effectiveness, but this is primarily from the USA. The present systematic review synthesised evidence for international interventions, exploring potential transportability and adaptability to the UK. We constructed an evidence map, and syntheses of intervention effectiveness, process evaluations and economic evaluations. We conducted seven stakeholder consultations with care-experienced young people, carers and professionals, to appraise transportability and adaptability. We identified sixty-four interventions, with 124 associated study reports. Seventy-seven were from the USA. There was limited effectiveness in targeting mental health, although there were promising approaches. Few approaches targeted well-being and suicide. Context factors, identified by the review and confirmed by stakeholders, may inhibit delivery: insufficient resources; time, emotional and cognitive burden; challenging interprofessional relationships; non-responsiveness to young people’s needs; and discounting of carers’ knowledge. Stakeholders recommended peer mentoring by other care-experienced individuals and system-change models that facilitate an attachment and/or trauma-informed ethos. Adaptation of existing approaches may be required to account for the context factors. Further intervention work is needed to target well-being and suicide.
U2 - 10.1093/bjsw/bcae061
DO - 10.1093/bjsw/bcae061
M3 - Article
SN - 0045-3102
VL - 54
SP - 3590
EP - 3618
JO - British Journal of Social Work
JF - British Journal of Social Work
IS - 8
ER -