A comparison of the clinical effectiveness and cost of specialized individually delivered parent training for preschool attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder and a generic, group based programme: a multi centre, randomised controlled trial of the New Forest Parenting Programme versus Incredible Years
Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review
Electronic versions
Documents
- 2017 A comparison of the clinical effectiveness
Final published version, 801 KB, PDF document
Licence: CC BY Show licence
DOI
The objective of this study is to compare the
efficacy and cost of specialised individually delivered parent
training (PT) for preschool children with attention-deficit/
hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) against generic group-based
PT and treatment as usual (TAU). This is a multi-centre
three-arm, parallel group randomised controlled trial
conducted in National Health Service Trusts. The participants
included in this study were preschool children (33–
54 months) fulfilling ADHD research diagnostic criteria.
New Forest Parenting Programme (NFPP)—12-week individual,
home-delivered ADHD PT programme; Incredible
Years (IY)—12-week group-based, PT programme initiallydesigned for children with behaviour problems were the
interventions. Primary outcome—Parent ratings of child’s
ADHD symptoms (Swanson, Nolan & Pelham Questionnaire—
SNAP-IV). Secondary outcomes—teacher ratings
(SNAP-IV) and direct observations of ADHD symptoms
and parent/teacher ratings of conduct problems. NFPP, IY
and TAU outcomes were measured at baseline (T1) and post
treatment (T2). NFPP and IY outcomes only were measured
6 months post treatment (T3). Researchers, but not therapists
or parents, were blind to treatment allocation. Analysis
employed mixed effect regression models (multiple imputations).
Intervention and other costs were estimated usingparent-rated SNAP-IV, ADHD combined symptoms [mean
difference − 0.009 95% CI (− 0.191, 0.173), p = 0.921] or
any other measure. Small, non-significant, benefits of NFPP
over TAU were seen for parent-rated SNAP-IV, ADHD
combined symptoms [− 0.189 95% CI (− 0.380, 0.003),
p = 0.053]. NFPP significantly reduced parent-rated conduct
problems compared to TAU across scales (p values
< 0.05). No significant benefits of IY over TAU were seen
for parent-rated SNAP, ADHD symptoms [− 0.16 95% CI
(− 0.37, 0.04), p = 0.121] or parent-rated conduct problems
(p > 0.05). The cost per family of providing NFPP in the
trial was significantly lower than IY (£1591 versus £2103).
Although, there were no differences between NFPP and IY
with regards clinical effectiveness, individually delivered
NFPP cost less. However, this difference may be reduced
when implemented in routine clinical practice. Clinical decisions
should take into account parental preferences between
delivery approaches
Keywords
- ADHD · New Forest · Parenting Programme · NFPP · Parenting · Incredible Years · IY
Original language | English |
---|---|
Pages (from-to) | 797-809 |
Journal | European Child and Adolescent Psychiatry |
Volume | 27 |
Issue number | 6 |
Early online date | 30 Oct 2017 |
DOIs | |
Publication status | Published - Jun 2018 |
Total downloads
No data available