In charge since time immemorial? Disused monumental features as markers of inherited social status.
Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding › Conference contribution › peer-review
Electronic versions
Documents
- karl
Final published version, 2.27 MB, PDF document
Licence: Unspecified
Some later Bronze and Iron Age settlements in Britain are characterised by enclosing features. Particularly on sites occupied continuously for considerable lengths of time, these features were re-configured ever so often. Some of the old banks and ditches seem to have become disused, while others were newly erected right next to them.
The construction of new, additional, banks and ditches – a process usually referred to as ‘multivallation’ – has often been interpreted as an expression of social competition. By investing in conspicuous consumption of labour, communities would express their social and economic potency. Grandiose displays of monumentalised settlement architecture – often ‘useless’ in terms of defence or any other ‘practical’ purpose – would show that a community had resources to spare.
But why, then, let some of the old banks crumble? In this paper, it is argued that letting some banks crumble was at least equally significant as building new ones, because it demonstrated other, even more important qualities of a community: pedigree and permanence. New walls can easily be built by anyone, if he be sufficiently determined, including any social upstart. Old, crumbling banks, on the other hand, cannot easily be faked: they demonstrate that a community has been important since time immemorial, and thus has been, and can be, relied upon, not just today, but forever.
The construction of new, additional, banks and ditches – a process usually referred to as ‘multivallation’ – has often been interpreted as an expression of social competition. By investing in conspicuous consumption of labour, communities would express their social and economic potency. Grandiose displays of monumentalised settlement architecture – often ‘useless’ in terms of defence or any other ‘practical’ purpose – would show that a community had resources to spare.
But why, then, let some of the old banks crumble? In this paper, it is argued that letting some banks crumble was at least equally significant as building new ones, because it demonstrated other, even more important qualities of a community: pedigree and permanence. New walls can easily be built by anyone, if he be sufficiently determined, including any social upstart. Old, crumbling banks, on the other hand, cannot easily be faked: they demonstrate that a community has been important since time immemorial, and thus has been, and can be, relied upon, not just today, but forever.
Keywords
- ARCHAEOLOGY
Original language | English |
---|---|
Title of host publication | Interpretierte Eisenzeiten 7. Fallstudien - Methoden - Theorie. |
Subtitle of host publication | Tagungsbeiträge der 7. Linzer Gespräche zur interpretativen Eisenzeitarchäologie. |
Editors | Raimund Karl, Jutta Leskovar |
Place of Publication | Linz, Austria |
Publisher | Oberösterreichisches Landesmuseum |
Pages | 75-90 |
Volume | 47 |
ISBN (print) | 978-3-85474-333-0 |
Publication status | Published - 20 Dec 2017 |
Publication series
Name | Studien zur Kulturgeschichte von Oberösterreich |
---|---|
Publisher | Oberösterreichisches Landesmuseum |
Volume | 47 |
Research outputs (19)
- Published
Politics and Power
Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding › Chapter › peer-review
- Published
Interpretierte Eisenzeiten 7. Fallstudien - Methoden - Theorie. Tagungsbeiträge der 7. Linzer Gespräche zur interpretativen Eisenzeitarchäologie
Research output: Book/Report › Book › peer-review
- Published
Zeige mir, wie Du wohnst, dann sage ich Dir, wer Du bist
Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review
Prof. activities and awards (2)
Meillionydd season 8 (2017)
Activity: Participating in or organising an event › Participation in Academic workshop, seminar, course
In charge since time immemorial? Disused monumental features as markers of inherited social status
Activity: Talk or presentation › Oral presentation
Projects (7)
Meillionydd - Season 8 (2017)
Project: Research
Meillionydd - Season 8 (2017)
Project: Research
Meillionydd - Season 7 (2016)
Project: Research
Total downloads
No data available