Selbstanzeige: unbewilligte Ausgrabung eines Weihnachtsmanns in Wien 13, Streitmanngasse 14 (2013)
Electronic versions
Documents
- Selbstanzeige Verstoss gegen DMSG 20131203
3.06 MB, PDF document
- MBA 01 - S 48902-13 Aufforderung an BDA zur Äußerung gemäß § 37 Abs 8 DMSG vom 20140320
554 KB, image/jpeg
- Magistrat Wien Einstellung Verwaltungsstrafverfahren 20140311
203 KB, PDF document
- Erledigungsschreiben 1
159 KB, PDF document
- DSC_3751
6.57 MB, image/jpeg
- DSC_3757
5.02 MB, image/jpeg
- DSC_3775
19.3 MB, application/octet-stream
- DSC_3783
7.49 MB, image/jpeg
- DSC_3795
8.36 MB, image/jpeg
- DSC_3802
8.73 MB, image/jpeg
- DSC_3811
8.4 MB, image/jpeg
- DSC_3815
8.39 MB, image/jpeg
- Raimund Karl - Organiser
Description
Self-reporting: unpermitted excavation of a Santa Claus figurine in Vienna, 13th district, Streitmanngasse 14 (2013).
To demonstrate that § 11 (1) Austrian Monuments Protection Law (DMSG) could not be applied in the way the Austrian National Heritage Agency (BDA) has argued consistently for decades, I conducted an unpermitted excavation in the front garden of my parents' house in Vienna for a bust of Santa Claus (acquired for this purpose in Bangor) buried there in my absence by my wife. This turned the bust into an 'archaeological monument' according to the provisions of § 8 (1) DMSG, which the BDA must not be excavated without a permit issued by it according to § 11 (1) DMSG. I reported myself for this 'illegal' excavation to the prosecuting authorities to get a judgement on the question, which was passed on 11/3/2014 in my favour. It was found in this judgement that I had not committed an illegal act by conducting this unpermitted excavation because the provisions of § 11 (1) DMSG did not apply to it. The BDA later claimed it had not been aware of this case and thus could not respond, as is a requirement unter § 37 (6) DMSG. This, however, cannot be, because the prosecuting authority had on record that it sent a request to the BDA to submit a statement on the case; leaving aside that I had copied the BDA into the CC of my original self-report to the prosecuting authority. All relevant records of the case are attached to this entry.
To demonstrate that § 11 (1) Austrian Monuments Protection Law (DMSG) could not be applied in the way the Austrian National Heritage Agency (BDA) has argued consistently for decades, I conducted an unpermitted excavation in the front garden of my parents' house in Vienna for a bust of Santa Claus (acquired for this purpose in Bangor) buried there in my absence by my wife. This turned the bust into an 'archaeological monument' according to the provisions of § 8 (1) DMSG, which the BDA must not be excavated without a permit issued by it according to § 11 (1) DMSG. I reported myself for this 'illegal' excavation to the prosecuting authorities to get a judgement on the question, which was passed on 11/3/2014 in my favour. It was found in this judgement that I had not committed an illegal act by conducting this unpermitted excavation because the provisions of § 11 (1) DMSG did not apply to it. The BDA later claimed it had not been aware of this case and thus could not respond, as is a requirement unter § 37 (6) DMSG. This, however, cannot be, because the prosecuting authority had on record that it sent a request to the BDA to submit a statement on the case; leaving aside that I had copied the BDA into the CC of my original self-report to the prosecuting authority. All relevant records of the case are attached to this entry.
19 Nov 2013 → 11 Mar 2014
Selbstanzeige: unbewilligte Ausgrabung eines Weihnachtsmanns in Wien 13, Streitmanngasse 14 (2013)
Duration | 19 Nov 2013 → 11 Mar 2014 |
---|---|
Location of event | Wien 13, Streitmanngasse 14 |
City | Vienna |
Country/Territory | Austria |
Degree of recognition | National event |
Event: Other
Event
Title | Selbstanzeige: unbewilligte Ausgrabung eines Weihnachtsmanns in Wien 13, Streitmanngasse 14 (2013) |
---|---|
Date | 19/11/13 → 11/03/14 |
Location | Wien 13, Streitmanngasse 14 |
City | Vienna |
Country/Territory | Austria |
Degree of recognition | National event |
Keywords
- Archaeology
Research outputs (6)
- Published
Authorities and subjects? The legal framework for public participation in Austrian archaeology
Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review
- Published
Sachlichkeitsgebot und archäologische Denkmalpflege
Research output: Other contribution
- Published
Wie (Denkmalschutz-) Gesetze funktionieren sollten
Research output: Other contribution
Prof. activities and awards (5)
Public Participation in Austria. Promoted, Permitted, or Prohibited?
Activity: Talk or presentation › Invited talk
Antrag auf Erteilung einer Genehmigung gem. § 11 Abs. 1 DMSG für archäologische Surveys und eine Grabung in Wien 13, Streitmanngasse 14
Activity: Participating in or organising an event › Participation in Academic workshop, seminar, course
Antrag auf Erteilung einer Genehmigung gem. § 11 Abs. 1 DMSG für eine Oberflächenfundaufsammlung in Wien 13, Streitmanngasse 14
Activity: Participating in or organising an event › Participation in Academic workshop, seminar, course